Matt-Merrill's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Gooberstory]

well...

yeah the graphics and animation are pretty amazing, but I think that was way longer than it needed to be... especially with how little of it actually contributed to the story... I dunno, maybe there's more that I'm missing, but a lot of it just seemed like random shots of scenery or animals that didn't have anything to do with the actual story. Also, the intro credits were much to long... they either need to be shortened or there needs to be more happening during them so people don't get bored too quickly. Sorry, to sound rather negative, I still thought the movie was good, I'm just trying to give helpful critisism to maybe help with future releases...

[Knives!]

hmm

Kinda funny but a little too random. I would have left out the weird guy in the car.... the time put into doing it (thought I doubt it took that long to move the car around and open and close the guy's mouth) could have been better spent making more scenarios for throwing the knives... or maybe a less abrupt ending, heh heh.

[Nim's Winter tale]

oooh

very nice animation here. beutiful scenery and great looking snow.

a little lacking in the story I thought, but not too bad. But it sure looked great and I 'm guessing a lot of your goal with this movie was probably in the visual delight. compliments to the musician as well. It fit the movie pretty well.

[the Animator and the Seat]

nice

hey that was animated reeally well!! good job!

[(2005) Hotdog Job: Part 1]

pretty boring...

knox... c'mon, man. This stuff is getting so old. you need to put more effort into your work. You're only impressing the little kids (who aren't very hard to please at all).

[The 5 Shades of Blue]

For ZekeySpaceyLizard

Zekey's was AmAZING! Nice story, I lOved your water animation, and great song choice! Everything about it made me happy. Definitely the best video in this collaboration.

[Robenstein]

nice visuals but not much else

Hey, it looked really nice, but there wasn't much of a story to it therefor just makin it kinda boring. Maybe that's because it took so long to do the graphics... but in my opinion awesome graphics and no story isn't as good as mediocer (sp?) graphics and a good story. Still, good work, I'm impressed. Now just put those graphic skills to good use!

[Stairway To Heaven]

pretty lame...

I just read the last 2 or 3 pages of reviews and apparently the only reason you are getting any points is for the song you used. People really shouldn't give movies good scores for the sole purpose of music, especially when you didn't even make it, but seriously, you should work on more of a story... that was a really random video. and I think most people are tired of the fruit clocks.

[I'm Blue»»»]

good start

That was pretty good. It would have been really awesome to see the guy do some break dancing or something though instead of just moving his arms back and forth. And you spent too long on that shot of the ipod or whatever it was with the bars bouncing up and down. But those are my only real complaints. It was definitely better than what I was expecting to see from a noob =P

[Sheik's a woman?]

umm

I don't know if you saw it, but someone did like this same thing like a week ago. and tHEY were ripping it off of the Real legend of Zelda video. I'm assuming you saw at least one of those... you should really come up with your own ideas.